Parker Jotter vs Parker 51

My perfect ink/cartridge is Pilot G2 0.38mm. I’ve tried tons of others, fountain pens, space pens, but always come back to the G2.

Only works with bottled ink, but even by writing several pages (probably 20 at max) each day, I fill it once a month (or every 2 weeks depending on usage). The MK II model I use is less expensive and plain than the MK V that's around on eBay for around 40 bucks, even though the latter is worth every penny it costs.

For decades, Parker pens have been my pleasure and passion. They disappeared from stores several years ago and reappeared a few weeks ago in an online ad. I ordered several, and expect to order more as part of other orders to try to keep them in reach. We are all entitled to our pleasures; Parker pens are among mine

I have no real requirements other than a nice, interesting writing experience (either because it's a flex/stub or because it writes beautifully, like a Parker 51, or whatever other reason), but I admit I'll start balking if the price climbs too high unless there's a good justification - I plan on using this pen, so something like a Namiki is out of the question since I'd be terrified to get those pieces of art dirty or drop it or lose it. I don't know what to choose, though, so I'm going to put it out there for opinions.

* 37 g is too heavy, so lighter than that...or maybe the pen I'm comparing to is just poorly balanced?

Otherwise it's a nice pen, although weighted toward the top (as another reviewer pointed out in a review of the blue/silver version); the Parker Sonnet ballpoint I have is better balanced. Uses twist action and comes filled with a black medium Parker Quinkflow refill.

I find I have to grip skinny pens harder to hold it in place, which puts more stress on my finger muscles. The slick gloss finish does not help grip when your fingers get a bit oily. There are matte finish 849 that may be grippier.

The grip would be a concern, however if you like the experience on the Parker 51 I’d be inclined to say you’d like the one on the Lamy, it’s also a hooded nib, after all.

Beautiful pen that has great endurance and is well manufactured...I have been using for 20 years and is well worth its price!

This pen is really, really disappointing. 1. The nib is cheap and scratchy. Not well made