Wirecutter

This comforter is lofty, warm, and well constructed, with a proven track record of quality. But it’s frequently out of stock.

Best for Most

bazaarvoice

expert-review

L.L. Bean Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter Review

This down comforter is better than any other we found for less than $200—it’s lofty and warm with a beautifully soft shell, but its down isn’t ethically certified.

Upgrade Pick

amazon.com

This warm-and-cozy down comforter is a smart choice for children and teens because it comes in a dozen colors, it doesn’t need a separate cover, and it’s easy to wash.

Budget Pick

TechGearLab

The Three Geese Pinch Pleat Goose Down is an incredible down duvet insert. This model is warm, cozy, and aesthetically pleasing. It's generously packed with 750-fill power down and perfect in the fall, winter, and spring. It's reliably and uniformly warm due to the baffle box construction that minimizes insulation shifting around. We tested the 90" x 90" queen size, which was an ample size for a queen bed. It feels heavier than many others, so if you like the feel of a lighter weighted blanket, this is a great option. We were treated to cozy, deep winter sleep with the Three Geese comforter. When you're not asleep, it supplies an upscale appearance, thanks to its loft and pinch pleat. We kept a duvet cover on top to avoid having to clean it too often. 
The manufacturer's care instructions advise you to dry clean the Three Geese Pinch Pleat, which can be expensive and time-consuming. The 1200-thread count cotton outer material is also loud and crinkly when rolling around in the bed. A duvet cover should help with both of these issues because it can reduce the noise and cleaning frequency. Despite these shortcomings, this is our favorite comforter due to its superb value, warmth, and overall comfort.

The Three Geese Pinch Pleat Goose Down is an incredible down duvet insert. This model is warm, cozy, and aesthetically pleasing. It's generously packed with 750-fill power down and perfect in the fall, winter, and spring. It's reliably and uniformly warm due to the baffle box construction that minimizes insulation shifting around. We tested the 90" x 90" queen size, which was an ample size for a queen bed. It feels heavier than many others — fans of weighted blankets may appreciate this. We were treated to cozy, deep winter sleep with the Three Geese comforter. When you're not asleep, it supplies an upscale appearance, thanks to its loft and pinch pleat, but we kept a duvet cover on top to avoid having to clean it too often. 
The manufacturer's care instructions advise you to dry clean the Three Geese Pinch Pleat, which can be expensive and time-consuming. The 1200-thread count cotton outer material is also loud and crinkly when rolling around in the bed. A duvet cover should help with both of these issues because it can reduce the noise and cleaning frequency. Despite these shortcomings, this is our favorite comforter due to its superb value, warmth, and overall comfort.

walmart

Save money in the long run with this well-constructed, lofty, 700-fill-power comforter, which has quality stitching and fabric that will last decades.

This gorgeous (and pricey) down comforter is much loftier than any other we’ve ever tried—imagine being enveloped in a luxurious cloud. It’s also made to last a long, long time.

stamped

Feathered Friends Bavarian 700 Down Comforter Review

The COSYBAY 100% Cotton Quilted Down is excellent if you're searching for a down option that won't break the bank. This product gives you the warmth and breathability of down without the traditional hassle of dry cleaning. This model is our recommendation if you have been interested in down options but strayed away because of the price and maintenance demands.
This product is mostly comprised of feathers rather than down. Feathers behave differently and have a quill that can poke you if it escapes out of the fabric. Feather products tend to have a shorter life span and less loft than true down. We have yet to notice any pokes in our testing, but we did notice a difference in loft between the down and feathered products; this is probably due to a difference in down fill and construction. The cover is also a cotton shell that is quite crinkly when moving around under the covers. If an excellent deal on a real down contender is what you're looking for, this is our top recommendation.

The COSYBAY 100% Cotton Quilted Down is excellent if you're searching for a down option that won't break the bank. This product gives you the warmth and breathability of down without the traditional hassle of dry cleaning. This model is our recommendation if you have been interested in down options but strayed away because of the price and maintenance demands.
This product is mostly comprised of feathers rather than down. Feathers behave differently and have a quill that can poke through the fabric encasing — not a pleasant feeling to have in bed! Feather products tend to have a shorter life span and less loft than true down. We have yet to notice any pokes in our testing, but we did notice a difference in loft between the down and feathered products; this is probably due to a difference in down fill and construction. The cover is also a cotton shell that is quite crinkly when moving around under the covers. If an excellent deal on a real down contender is what you're looking for, this is our top recommendation.

This high-quality down comforter is fluffy, lightweight, and very warm on a chilly night. It’s also one of the few comforters we’ve seen that didn’t have major stock problems during the pandemic.

Down Comforter Comparison