LooriaLooria
Open menu

Eyeliner Comparison

11 results
Reset
award-badge

Best for Most

in Eyeliner

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner
A

50 reviews

$22
·
stilacosmetics
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Eyeliner
•
Great for long-wearing
•
Easy to apply
•
Intense color
•
Poor twist up ability
•
Goes on smooth
award-badge

Upgrade Pick

in Eyeliner

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner
A

90 reviews

$36
·
dillards
$26
·
ebay (USED)
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Eyeliner
•
Great for lining the eye
•
Easy to blend
•
Dries up halfway before you've used it all
•
Vial dries out very quickly
•
Runs unless the waterline is also powdered with eyeshadow
award-badge

Budget Pick

in Eyeliner

Inglot Duraline
B

50 reviews

$19
·
norcostco
$19
·
inglotusa
award-badge
#156 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for aging hooded eyes
•
Does not smudge
•
Long lasting
•
May be difficult to find in stores
•
Requires mixing with eyeshadow
NYX Epic Ink Liner
A

113 reviews

award-badge
#1 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for the price
•
Pigment is good
•
Bristles get messed up easily
•
Difficult to clean
•
Causes bubbles
KVD Tattoo Liner
B

123 reviews

award-badge
#23 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for oily eyelids
•
Easily smudges
•
Takes a long time to dry
•
Peels off easily
•
Difficult to apply
Nyx Epic Wear
B

97 reviews

award-badge
#72 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for beginners
•
Easy to use
•
Long lasting
•
Good value for money
•
Comes in a variety of colors
Nyx Matte Liquid Liner
B

65 reviews

award-badge
#20 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for those who want a long-wearing eyeliner
•
Tip is too long and pliant
•
Difficult to control
•
Gets all over the eyelid when applying
•
May be difficult to remove
Suva Beauty Hydra Liner
C

7 reviews

$9
·
morphe
award-badge
#139 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for bold colors and graphic eyeliner
•
Comes with a brush
•
Easy to use
•
Long lasting
•
Good value for money
E.l.f. Lock On Liner And Brow Cream
C

62 reviews

•
Great for people who like bold eyebrows
•
Goes on strong or weak
•
Not as smooth as Rimmel eyebrow duo
•
Too dark for some people
•
Taupe-Blonde color looks closer to real hair color
Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner
C

80 reviews

$7
·
buymebeauty
$8
·
Amazon
award-badge
#164 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for everyday use
•
Easy to apply
•
Long lasting
•
Does not smudge or fade
•
Comes in black and brown
E.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner
?

104 reviews

award-badge
#163 most mentioned
Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction
•
Great for black and the corner of your eyes
•
Not smudge proof
•
Easy to apply
•
Starts to smear after a few hours
•
Light brown