Wirecutter

The polyester and cotton-lined Homwe oven mitt allowed us to hold a 400 °F cast-iron skillet for an average of 11 seconds. Its silicone exterior is easy to maneuver, and it’s water-resistant, too.

In addition to being heat-proof, the silicone exterior of this oven mitt is grippy, easy to maneuver, and water resistant, while the polyester-cotton lining adds extra protection and comfort.

TechGearLab

Although we like the length of these mitts, even people with larger hands might find the fit to be a little loose. A baggy fit can make grasping smaller items somewhat tricky. The length of the cuff also makes one-handed donning and doffing a tall order unless they're hanging from a hook. Finally, the lining is not secured, so if you aren't careful, wet hands can cling to the material and cause them to turn inside out. 

amazon.com

walmart

Although these terry-lined silicone mitts are a little pricey, they’re the best-looking option we’ve found for mitts that offer good coverage.

bazaarvoice

yotpo

The Maison d' Hermine Double Oven Mitt offers users superb hand and forearm protection. The model is easy to hang over a cupboard door or on an oven handle. The construction is of high quality, and the insulation is more than adequate. We also appreciate that this particular style of holder has pockets for the hands to slide into, making it easy to grab cookware while providing complete protection to vulnerable skin. 
On the flip side, these holders are large when compared to other models in the class. As a result, if you're using just one hand, the extra material can get in the way. The loose material combined with all-cotton construction increases the likelihood of permanent stains. Concerns aside, we were impressed with the effectiveness of this design when using both hands, as well as the sturdy construction of the product.  

expert-review

Best Pot Holders of 2022

If you're frequently baking with cast iron or roasting on high heat, the Big Red House mitts provide superior protection for kitchen crucibles. In an insulation test with a six-pound cast iron pan heated to 500º F, our testers struggled to maintain their grip on the heavy pan for the 41 seconds it took for the heat to bleed through. The cotton insulation not only provides prolonged protection, the 4 ½" cuffs supply forearm shielding for all but the deepest ovens.
While these mitts have ample heat resistance, we found them to be not the most sensitive for gripping pot lids or the ears of casserole dishes. This product's durability also caused concern amongst testers as it only took minimal strain for the hook loops to tear out. Aside from the torn loop issue, the rest of the construction appears solid, with the main seams sporting three-thread overlock stitching. Overall, these mitts' superior heat protection outweighs their shortcomings.  

If you're frequently baking with cast iron or roasting on high heat, the Big Red House Oven Mitts provide superior protection for kitchen crucibles. In an insulation test with a six-pound cast iron pan heated to 500º F, our testers struggled to maintain their grip on the heavy pan for the 41 seconds it took for the heat to bleed through. The cotton insulation not only provides prolonged protection, the 4 ½" cuffs supply forearm shielding for all but the deepest ovens.
While these mitts have ample heat resistance, we found them to be not the most sensitive for gripping pot lids or the ears of casserole dishes. This product's durability also caused concern amongst testers as it only took minimal strain for the hook loops to tear out. Aside from the torn loop issue, the rest of the construction appears solid, with the main seams sporting three-thread overlock stitching. Overall, these mitts' superior heat protection outweighs their shortcomings.  

arcus-www.amazon.com

target

The LoveU. gloves are unique oven gloves that offer decent heat protection, superb grip, and delightful dexterity. Their exterior is comprised completely of silicone, making them easy to clean since silicone is naturally resistant to liquids or stain-causing oils. We found these gloves' grippy nature to be quite useful when handling the small ears of pie dishes, removing pyrex and cast iron lids, or cranking open tight jar lids. Finally, these gloves are available in two size options — one size fits most and L/XL — to accommodate a range of users.
While these gloves offer many attributes, they are not a prime choice for high heat. When gripping a 500ºF cast iron panhandle, the heat bled through to our tester's hand in a mere 8 seconds. That level of insulation provides roughly enough time to transfer a hot item from the oven to the stovetop. However, if you frequently bake or cook at super high temperatures, we recommend picking a more suitable option. The fit might also be too baggy for some. Although, the loose fit does make it a cinch to get these gloves on and off with one hand.    

The LoveU. Silicone gloves are unique oven gloves that offer decent heat protection, superb grip, and delightful dexterity. Their exterior is comprised completely of silicone, making them easy to clean since silicone is naturally resistant to liquids or stain-causing oils. We found these gloves' grippy nature to be quite useful when handling the small ears of pie dishes, removing pyrex and cast iron lids, or cranking open tight jar lids. Finally, these gloves are available in two size options — one size fits most and L/XL — to accommodate a range of users.
While these gloves offer many attributes, they are not a prime choice for high heat. When gripping a 500ºF cast iron panhandle, the heat bled through to our tester's hand in a mere 8 seconds. That level of insulation provides roughly enough time to transfer a hot item from the oven to the stovetop. However, if you frequently bake or cook at super high temperatures, we recommend picking a more suitable option. The fit might also be too baggy for some. Although, the loose fit does make it a cinch to get these gloves on and off with one hand.    

These gloves offer more dexterity than a mitt or a pot holder, but they’re less heat-proof.

Oven Mitt Comparison